Home > Events & News > Brown Bag Schedule . Archive

PSC In The News

RSS Feed icon

Kruger says reports of phantom mobile phone ringing/vibrating more common among anxious

Stafford says too early to say whether stock market declines will curtail Americans' spending

Eisenberg says many colleges now train campus personnel to spot and refer troubled college students

Highlights

Call for papers: Conference on Integrating Genetics and the Social Sciences, Oct 21-22, 2016, CU-Boulder

PRB training program in policy communication for pre-docs. Application deadline, 2.28.2016

Call for proposals: PSID small grants for research on life course impacts on later life wellbeing

PSC News, fall 2015 now available

Next Brown Bag

Monday, Feb 1 at noon, 6050 ISR-Thompson
Sarah Miller

psc brown bag iconGenuine Fakes: The prevalence and implications of data fabrication in a large South African survey

Vimal Ranchhod (University of Cape Town)

10/14/2013, 12:00:00, 6050 ISR - Thompson

Archived video

How prevalent is data fabrication by fieldworkers in South African surveys? Does this substantially affect the validity of subsequent empirical analyses? We document how we diagnosed such misbehaviour in the longitudinal National Income Dynamics Study. We found that the existence of fabrication was non-trivial, and affected about 7% of the sample. Since the fabrication was detected while fieldwork was still on-going, the relevant interviews were re-conducted and the fabricated data was replaced with authentic data. We thus have an observed counterfactual that allows us to measure how problematic such fabrication would have been, had it remained undetected. We implement a number of estimators using the data that includes the fabricated interviews, and compare these with the corresponding estimates that include the corrected data instead. For the outcomes that we consider, we find that while the two estimates do differ, the magnitudes of the differences are small and generally not substantial. This occurs for two reasons. Firstly, the fraction of fabricated data is relatively small, and secondly, the fabricated data is not too different from the corrected data. We conclude with a policy discussion for survey organizations that might have similar concerns.


  View All